Now we open the vault! As promised,
here is an example of the production company coverage that is generated once a
script makes it into “the pile.” Remember, it’s a story analyst’s job to
prepare a CE for detailed meetings about this script and to protect the CE from reading a script that is not
production-worthy. Can your script pass this test?
"VERY BIG PRODUCTION COMPANY"
MATERIAL: screenplay,
book, etc. |
TITLE: title |
|
|
NUMBER OF
PAGES: ## |
AUTHOR: author’s name |
|
|
PUB/DATE: for books |
GENRE: drama, comedy, etc. |
|
|
SUBMITTED BY:
rep, if any |
CIRCA: time period |
|
|
SUBMITTED
TO: CE’s
name |
LOCATION: city
or setting |
|
|
ANALYST: reader’s name |
ELEMENTS: attachments |
LOG LINE: A young boy is
shuttled via Amtrak between his two separating parents.
COMMENT
SUMMARY:
A passive protagonist with no focused objective wades through a piecemeal approach
to the same old situation: Neglected Child of Divorce.
|
EXCELLENT |
GOOD |
FAIR |
POOR |
Idea |
|
|
|
X |
Story Line |
|
|
|
X |
Structure |
|
|
X |
|
Characters |
|
|
|
X |
Dialogue |
|
|
X |
|
Budget: High X Medium Low
PROJECT
RECOMMENDATION: PASS
WRITER
RECOMMENDATION: PASS
SYNOPSIS
When
13-year-old geek ROBBIE FRENCH’s parents separate, he’s dragged off to Newport
with his weak-willed dad MARTIN FRENCH. In the course of being shuttled by
train between his dad and his mom (ABBY FRENCH), Robbie has only a pissed off
kitty and some comic books for company until he meets another bad parenting-product,
14-year-old MARK HERBERT. After an inexplicable brawl through the aisles of the
train, the two boys become friends. Meanwhile Robbie’s loser dad loses job
after job and his libidinal mom hops from guy to guy.
Robbie
parents his dad, feels like an outcast in his neighborhood and silently resents
his mom’s boyfriends. He even gets a tattoo, only to discover the shady biker
tattoo artist couldn’t spell – but no one notices the tattoo. When his dad
loses yet another job and can’t make rent, Robbie toys with designing his own
comic book to earn some money. In the midst of one of their shared train rides,
Robbie and Mark carjack a cab from a stringy-haired pothead, and Robbie crashes
a major comic book company to pitch his first story. He’s booted out of the
publishing offices, only to be stuck in the middle of an unfamiliar city when
Mark is hauled away for the carjacking.
When
Robbie’s newly divorced mom chooses to stay on her second honeymoon rather than
rescue her son, his dad cancels his own pity party to save Robbie, finally
accepting responsibility for his child. The two start to take the train back
together, leaving Mark unaccounted for, until they both realize neither has the
money for a return ticket. Now they both are stranded in an unfamiliar city,
but at least they are together.
COMMENTS
When
faced with a “child-of-divorce” piece, the first instinct is to search for a
new twist. This script, however, offers nothing beyond the most basic beats:
parental selfishness and neglect, child-as-misfit in new environment, child
resenting parent’s new loves, child becoming parent. The main weakness,
therefore, is its lack theme, inspiration and originality. Moreover, it fails
to tell a coherent story, however unoriginal, in the course of too many (140!)
pages.
This
script doesn’t know what it wants to be. Is it the story of a youngster who
finds identity and escape through comic book art? No. Robbie’s comic book
obsession is just a geeky quirk to justify his having no friends that becomes a
niggle halfway through the script, is dropped, then becomes a full-blown
mission at the end of the story. It should have been established as the mission
at the top of the screenplay if it’s going to be utilized in the climax.
Unless,
of course, this is a coming-of-age story. The script does include Robbie’s
first fight, first train ride, etc. But he doesn’t change or mature in the
course of any of the script’s events, so that negates that possibility.
All
of Robbie’s scenes with his father are the role reversing beat of son-as-father.
All the scenes of Robbie and his mother are the beat of a fun-loving-but-inept mom
who can’t choose between being a lover or a parent. At the end, the dad does
grow up, and the mom does choose (badly), but Robbie, the Main Character,
remains the same. So what you ultimately get is a series of snippets glued
together by train trips and a lot of talking.
Structure,
of course, is a lost cause without story. Still, there’s no detectable initial
change – even if you cheat and go to the end to see what the story was driving
towards. Robbie doesn’t start out wanting to create comic books, so the meeting
at the publishing company isn’t a climax. Robbie’s parents are already
separated when we begin. And the character who “turns” at the end of the script
is his dad--who has held one pitiful, job-losing, repeating beat throughout the
script until this moment. But he is sacrificing nothing (he has nothing), so it
means nothing. With neither a beginning nor an end for the protagonist, the
middle of the script has no meaning either. Robbie isn’t fully embracing or
rejecting anything because there is no issue driving Robbie to do anything in
the first place.
Robbie
is not just stagnant; he is completely unbelievable in his actions. On his
first train trip, Robbie’s fear of leaving home alone is compounded by fear of the
foo-foo cat trying to kill him through the gate of his gazillion-dollar
carrying case. Robbie never moves, fights back or complains or even mentions
this trauma to his mom when he arrives, nor does the incident trigger any
future events in the story. In fact, none of Robbie’s actions have consequences
– he tattoos his foot with a typo, but no one notices, and the tattoo never
comes up again. He tells off his mother’s boyfriends but doesn’t get in
trouble, and he resolves every frustration with his dad by getting on a train
to return to his mom, despite her neglectful parenting.
At
home, Robbie consistently takes care of his loser dad and never gets fed up or
rebels. The few choices he finally makes – carjacking a cab? – hardly connect him
to the audience or demonstrate any signs of growth or change. Between his
inexplicable actions and the unrealistic way his parents deal with him (bedtime
stories and boogeyman checks for a 13-year-old?), he is impossible to relate to
or root for. Meanwhile, his father messes up in job after job without ever
growing or worsening from the experiences. He clings to his ex-wife in e-mail
after e-mail, never giving up or becoming angry enough at her indifference to
actually try something new. Most incredibly, neither Robbie nor his dad hold his
mother accountable for leaving Robbie alone in a strange city at midnight – the
one time rejection and a raging tantrum would have been appropriate. In fact,
that was the one last shot at a climax the script had…and nothing happened. Instead,
there were just two idiots in the train station instead of one.
The
dialogue is as flat as the characters and is written too on-the-nose. Also, at one point the author switches into
voice-over mode (never to recur) which takes us completely out of the script.
In
short, this screenplay offers nothing new: no new story, new twists, new
characters, new voices or new revelations. It’s not even a funny or moving journey
through an old story. It’s a story that needs not be told – and, in fact, isn’t.
******
At this point, it is probably clear
that neither this script nor this writer is moving forward at this production
company – unless it was written by Mega Star’s entire entourage (or your CE’s
brother-in-law…or a power agent’s favorite client…). In the absence of a connection
like that, the writer will not even get detailed notes on why the script was
rejected. Instead, the script will be filed away in the company library, and both
the screenplay and writer will be databased as a “Pass.”
Commit to The “1-3-5” for your first submission to any
potential buyer. Then commit to it again for the next.
Happy writing, pitching and selling!